Truth Alliance Newsletter Signup
     Follow Us   |   Truth Alliance RSS Link     Truth Alliance Facebook Link     Truth Alliance Channel     Truth Alliance Live Documentaries
  Archive > News
Search

Court Allows torture lawsuit against Rumsfeld

AP | Aug. 8, 2011

A lawsuit accusing former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld of personal responsibility for U.S. forces allegedly torturing two American whistleblowers who worked for an Iraqi contracting firm will be allowed to move forward, a federal appeals court ruled Monday.

The ruling from the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago comes just days after a similar decision by a federal judge in Washington, D.C., that gave the green light to an Army veteran — who also alleges he was tortured in Iraq — to sue Rumsfeld for damages.

Monday's ruling rejected arguments that Rumsfeld should be immune from such lawsuits for work performed as a Cabinet secretary.

The U.S. Supreme Court sets a high bar for those suing a top government official, mandating that they show the acts in question are tied directly to a violation of constitutional rights and that the official clearly understood they were violations.

"There can be no doubt that the deliberate infliction of such treatment on U.S. citizens, even in a war zone, is unconstitutional," U.S. Circuit Judge David Hamilton wrote in Monday's opinion.

An attorney for Rumsfeld blasted the ruling.

"Having judges second-guess the decisions made by the armed forces halfway around the world is no way to wage a war," David Rivkin, Jr., said in a written statement. "It saps the effectiveness of the military, puts American soldiers at risk, and shackles federal officials who have a constitutional duty to protect America."

In their lawsuit, Donald Vance and Nathan Ertel claim U.S. forces detained them in 2006 after they alleged illegal activities by the Iraqi-owned company they worked for, Shield Group Security.

Among the methods of torture used against them during several weeks in military camps was sleep deprivation and a practice known as "walling," in which subjects are blindfolded and walked into walls, according to the lawsuit.

The lawsuit alleges Rumsfeld personally participated in approving the methods for use by the U.S. military in Iraq, making Rumsfeld responsible, it argues, for what happened to Vance and Ertel.

Their attorney, Mike Kanovitz, welcomed the ruling, saying the court faced a choice between "protecting the most fundamental rights of American citizens in the difficult context of a war or leaving those rights solely in the hands of politicians and the military."

"It was not an easy choice for the Court to make, but it was the brave and right choice," Kanovitz said in a written statement.

A spokesman for the U.S. Department of Justice, which represents Rumsfeld in the case, declined comment on the ruling.

But Rivkin said he believes the decision will eventually be overturned.


Related

America's Black-Ops Blackout: Unraveling the Secrets of the Military's Secret Military
U.S. cracks open skies to testing, use of aerial drones
Black Budget: US govt clueless about missing Pentagon $trillions
Washington Post, its new owner, and the CIA: joined at the hip
Report claims CIA program has helped kill two dozen Colombian rebel leaders
Rasmussen: Only 31% of Americans Work 40-Hour Week
Russia Warns America ‘We Will Respond With Nukes’
U.S. Sells Off Last of Its General Motors Stock, at $10.5 Billion Loss
Feds Spent $180k On Liquor Days Before & During Government Shutdown
Obama war chiefs widen drone kill box

Tags

CIA, Donald Rumsfeld, U.S., Pentagon, Torture

Civil Liberties :: 1329 Views :: 1 Comments
Comments
By sparkplug on Friday, August 12, 2011 @ 3:04 AM
Finally.
It is obvious that judges at all levels are becoming increasingly cognizant of the fact that their duties in the position vastly transcend the nature of their appointment. Serving the legal interests of the citizenry of the U.S.A., thus the U.S.A., vastly supersedes brown-nosing the politician who made the appointment.
Congratulations, patriots.

Only registered users may post comments.
© Copyright 2007-2013 Truth Alliance inc. All Rights Reserved